What is the Argument Against a New Constitution?

Artur Davis came out hard and fast on constitutional reform today.  It is clear he is going to make this a center piece of his campaign, and I applaud him strongly for that effort.  While I have been a strong supporter of the need for a new constitution in Alabama for some time, I have also expressed doubt about the ability to convince my fellow citizens of the proposition.  I sincerely hope that Artur is the man to make that argument to the people of Alabama and win the day.

What is truly disconcerting to me is that I have yet to hear a well-thought out, evidence-based argument for NOT proceeding with trying to write a new constitution.  The arguments I have heard and debated with those who say they oppose the effort are all based on WHO is backing the effort for a new constitution and fear of what it might produce.  But both of those arguments are easy to knock down.  Even if the effort is being supported by “left wing” or “liberal” groups as some claim, the delegates who go to the convention would be voted on by ALL of the people of their district.  They would then come together and have to agree on a document.  THEN that document would have to be voted on by the people.  Does anyone really believe that a group of Alabama citizens is going to write a document that is radically out of step with the views of most Alabamians and that that document would then be passed in a statewide vote?  Come on…

I have asked on Twitter and even debated Pascal Caputo, a lobbyist and once aide to Senator Shelby, on the issue.  But I have yet to get an honest, fact-based response that makes sense.  Let the people call a convention.  Let the people write a document.  Let the people have an up-or-down vote.  That’s all we ask, and that’s all those who support a constitution have ever asked.

Please comment below, I’m interested in your thoughts.

Related posts:

1. Support House Joint Resolution 91 It doesn’t look likely, but the plan for a...
2. The “Strong” Argument Against Healthcare as a Moral Issue On August 25th the Montgomery Advertiser published the following...
3. An Argument Without One Single Fact… Lots of statements of fact from Marjorie Crawford in...
4. “Open Secret” Continues Push for Constitutional Reform The latest attempt by supporters of constitutional reform in...
5. Davis Says 25% will vote on race…I think it’s higher Eric Zimmerman at The Hill thinks the 25% number...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.