Alabama Politics Analyzed for your Protection
Friday September 3rd 2010

Being Knowledgeable Consumers of the News, Whatever the Source

I know this will shock some of my friends that want to continue to try to put me into an ideological box, but I think the Obama administration’s rant against Fox News is just another example of getting absorbed and distracted by the fluff over the substance.  I don’t have time for it when it comes from pundits and politicians on the right and I don’t have time for it when it comes from pundits and politicians on the left.

Every administration has their preferred media outlets, former VP Dick Cheney wouldn’t even let the New York Times travel with him, much less grant interviews.  I believe every savy news consumer should use a multitude of sources for their news and that all news outlets often get the facts wrong…TV media more often than print, but they all do it nonetheless.  Only by piecing together the various half-truths and incomplete analyses can you ever get to something that resembles what is really happening.

The reality is it’s impossible to be an expert on everything and that even when journalists are striving to be fair, they rely on experts for their stories, and therefore introduce bias.  The best journalism is in-depth journalism that tries to bring in as many perspectives as possible to start to reflect the whole picture, but most TV and newspaper news is not in-depth, it’s done on a short deadline and only scratches the surface of the real story. 

Personally, I have almost completely cut out TV news from my news consumption pattern, by personal choice.  I rely more on daily newspapers online, along with their comments that may inform as well as incite; commentary on websites and other online outlets; sites like Factcheck.org and Politifact.com that go behind the initial story and analyze it; and in-depth pieces in news magazines like the Atlantic and others.

Ever since my friend Dr. Taylor made this statement, I have returned to it for reference many times.  The biggest deficit we are dealing with in political debate today is the lack of ability to think critically.  That goes for people at every point on the political spectrum.  I seek out those who, whatever their political beliefs and ideology, are willing to look at and analyze facts to see another person’s point-of-view or perhaps arrive at a different conclusion.  The idea that every argument is equally valid is patently ridiculous, but it’s become a more and more commonly held belief. 

Of course, all sides of an argument have merit, but that doesn’t mean they have equal merit.  A skill that many have lost in the course of political debate is to acknowledge the truth that is embedded in every argument, but then responding to that truth with their own evidence  instead of ranting about the “lies” from the other side.  I struggle with that as much as the next person (as some of my interactions on Twitter will attest), but I can say I strive to be the person who brings reason and I know that when I take the time to reflect on what the other person is saying (and understand it) I can break down almost any barrier.

I hope this is read in the spirit it is intended, not as a diatribe against one side or the other, but a statement to those of all political persuassions to think before you speak or write and to consider honestly that the person you are responding to may have a world view that is different than yours, but that world view doesn’t make them good or bad.  And, finally, to read and observe ALL media (TV, radio, newspapers, magazines, websites and blogs) as also representing a point of view and analyze the information that is being presented critically.

As always, your thoughts and comments are appreciated below.

Liked this article? Read another similar article.
GD Star Rating
loading...
Being Knowledgeable Consumers of the News, Whatever the Source, 5.5 out of 10 based on 2 ratings
  • Share/Bookmark

Related posts:

  1. Alabama Candidates & Social Media Since it’s election day, I thought it entirely appropriate to...
  2. What is the Argument Against a New Constitution? Artur Davis came out hard and fast on constitutional reform...
  3. What’s Next for Susan Parker? Danny at Political Parlor and the AP noted earlier today...
  4. Summary of Alabama Polls: A New Page at TWAY I took a suggestion from Twitter today and ran with...
  5. Caption Contest – Parker Griffith Edition Photo Courtesy of the Huntsville Times  Provide your own captions...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

Reader Feedback

10 Responses to “Being Knowledgeable Consumers of the News, Whatever the Source”

  1. Kris says:

    NEW TWAY Blog Post: Being Knowledgeable Consumers of the News, Whatever the Source http://bit.ly/45YCWp #journalism #news #politics

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. [...] Read more from the original source: Being Knowledgeable Consumers of the News, Whatever the Source [...]

  3. alabamaBNN says:

    The World Around You: Being Knowledgeable Consumers of the News, Whatever the Source: I know this will shock some of… http://bit.ly/16TIgb

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Kris says:

    In case you missed it last night: TWAY Blog Post: Being Knowledgeable Consumers of the News, Whatever the Source http://bit.ly/45YCWp

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Ben Venable says:

    RT @michelle_cc: Critical thinking, politics, and news media : good article from @tway_kris http://bit.ly/4yxfIE

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by TWAY_Kris: NEW TWAY Blog Post: Being Knowledgeable Consumers of the News, Whatever the Source http://bit.ly/45YCWp #journalism #news #politics…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Yes we as a society have lost the ability to think critically. Too much sponging and not enough dissecting.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Tim says:

    You’ve given we media-types a lot to chew on.
    I agree with you that news consumers should use multiple sources to collect news, especially if those consumers are willing (and able) to recognize the obvious bias of many of those sources. For state news…the Birmingham News is fine (with a conservative bent, or course) and The Anniston Star is a nice balance. The Press-Register is another of the state’s papers with a consevative leaning…perhaps balanced by The Tuscaloosa News? Till the day when all papers are charging for online comment, that’s one way to get a fair view of what’s happening in the state. After that…will people pay for multiple sources? Perhaps not.
    As for TV..the average “sound bite” in TV News is now seven seconds. Obviously I make my living on TV, and do heartily recommend that it be included in the mix of sources for consumers. And please do not forget the Grandaddy of long-form TV News programs: 60-Minutes. I have yet to find another program that beats it for probing interviews and in-depth coverage. Frontline on PBS is another one.
    In the end, after the current media turmoil settles down, I still believe some kind of a daily summary service will remain popular with consumers…just as TV newscasts and the evening paper did for some many years. Will it be a blog or series of bogs? An audio recording? A computer servant who knows all of the stories you’ve read and suggests ones you might want? Who knows. But one thing for sure: there still is and always be a need to answer the question: what’s happening?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Kristopher says:

    You’re absolutely right Tim…and obviously news consumption patterns are already changing. Individual citizens have access to the equivalent of the AP wire and so media outlets are going to have to shift their role in order to remain viable. The editorial perspective is and will continue to become more important.

    I also like your thought about making people pay to comment on the big sites like AL.com, CNN, etc… Is that something you are hearing discussed?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. [...] a comment » over at the World Around You, Being Knowledgeable Consumers of the News, Whatever the Source.  FWIW, I’ve found as much to ponder from reading trotskyites as libertarians.  Also, [...]

Leave a Reply